| Platinum | The Re-Up San Angelo |
| Gold | The Latest Scoop |
| Silver | Halfmann's Cake Cottage |
| Silver | Sugar High Bake Shop |
| Bronze | Angelos Best Funnel Cakes |
| Top Pick | City Cafe & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Froyo & Sweets Downtown |
| Top Pick | Mr Elote |
| Top Pick | Pinguis Paleteria |
| Top Pick | Rusas Mexico |