| Platinum | Old Central Firehouse Pizzeria & Taproom |
| Gold | Angelo Ale House & Pizzeria |
| Silver | Lily's Pizza |
| Bronze | 1982 Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | Cicis Pizza |
| Top Pick | Doubledave's Pizzaworks |
| Top Pick | Newk's Eatery |
| Top Pick | Pizza Hut |
| Top Pick | Stango's Pizza Parlor |